Thursday, September 22, 2011

State of the Franchise - Kansas City Chiefs - Suck for Luck?



Well…what exactly can you say at this point?  I didn’t think that we would be here this early in the season but we are.  Phrases such as “what’ve we got to lose?” “it doesn’t really matter,” and “at least we’ll get a high draft pick,” that are usually reserved for late season futility are already being thrown around Kansas City with reckless abandon.  This is quite the unfortunate scenario we have here in KC as Chiefs fans.

Looking back at my Chiefs fandom I have found myself incredibly heartbroken over the years.  We don’t need to go back into all of the major heartbreaks (playoff losses and missed field goals).  I have also had many season of slowly induced pain, 2001’s 1-6 start and 6-10 finish in the first year of the Dick Vermeil era, 2004’s underwhelming 7-9 record after a spectacular yet incomplete 13-3 season the year before, and the 5-35 stretch that went from the last nine games of 2007 all the way to the final game of the 2009 season.  Yes, lots and lots of pain as a Chiefs fan, but I don’t know that I have felt quite like this before.



It is a feeling of hopelessness as a fan with a team in this situation.  Ravaged by injuries and seemingly ill-prepared, this team looks as though it might be beyond help.  We pride ourselves as fans with the ability to be armchair or Monday morning quarterbacks, coaches, and GMs.  We all pretend to have the ability to see what the Chiefs are doing wrong and what they need to do better.  Yet, we as fans don’t seem to be able to find a way to fix this.  It’s not something as simple as “fix the defense” or “get Matt Cassel more weapons” or even, “get rid of Matt Cassel,” this issue seems to be an epidemic that is sweeping through the organization and there seems to be little help in sight.

The question isn’t about how to help this team win, it’s simply a question from a disarray standpoint of, what is this organization going to do?  It’s a wait and see type of situation that this organization hasn’t been through in a long, long time.  It is a tough scenario we find ourselves in here in KC. 

Recently, there has been a lot of touting of the “Suck for Luck” campaign, in which people in KC are pushing for the Chiefs to win as few games as possible in the hope that they would get the overall #1 pick in next April’s draft and be able to select All-American Andrew Luck, who is the consensus best QB to come out of college in a long time.  Luck is undoubtedly a special talent and would be a welcome addition to KC, but at what cost?

Admittedly, for the Chiefs Super Bowl hopes, having a poor year and getting a franchise QB is better than going 6-10 and drafting whatever LSU player at #8 the Chiefs deem worthy.  However, this is a conundrum that many fanbases have found themselves in before.  Do you lose or root for your team to lose on purpose?  I am not sure if the Lions fans in Detroit turned on their organization and rooted for them to go 0-16 in 2008, but if they hadn’t done that bad, maybe they wouldn’t be sitting there today with a soon to be elite QB named Matt Stafford who is primed to have a career season.

While I would be lying if I said that it isn’t the best thing for the Chiefs to be in a position to draft Andrew Luck, am I to erode my fandom by clearly rooting against this team?  The team that this city has lived and died with for the last 50 years is on life support and the teams fans are contemplating pulling the plug as opposed to hoping they come out of the coma.  Pulling the plug might give some closure and allow us to move on to next year and possibly a new era with a new head coach and a new franchise QB, but with pulling the plug and ending our fandom this season, as the 2011 season dies, so will a little piece of our fanhood.

Fans don’t have to be eternally optimistic, rather, it is important that fans are eternally realistic and the reality of this situation is that the Chiefs are not going to be good this year.  However, while fans should be realistic, they should also eternally be fans, and root for this team no matter what.  Royals fans are excited this year due to the fact that, despite the win-loss record, there are many things to be positive about.  This is where the Chiefs season will be headed, with a lot of young players and a lot of situations where new players can shine.  While the record might not be much to look at we will have to look at positives that are grown through THIS team during THIS season.

Instead of “Suck for Luck” the Chiefs need to do the equivalent of what the Royals did in 2011 with Kyle Davies and others, cut bait and let their young guns sink or swim.  The Chiefs need depth and they need to fill holes, and it’s time to figure out how many holes they really need to fill this offseason.  Shut down Kelly Gregg and let Jerrell Powe (who hasn’t suited up yet), see if he has a future on this team.  Decrease the role of Thomas Jones and see if Leron McClain has what it takes and if Dexter McCluster truly is a viable option.  Let Casey Weiggman take a seat and throw Rodney Hudson in there to see what he’s got. 

Ultimately, if the Chiefs have nothing to lose, then they have a lot to gain.  I know I will be rooting for more to gain, while I have craved a franchise QB in KC my whole life, I know that I will keep rooting for this team to figure things out and get better, if that costs us a chance at Andrew Luck, then so be it, I am with this team no matter what the scenario.  Who knows, they may find themselves at the end of the season in a better position than they thought and wind up looking forward to 2012.

No comments:

Post a Comment